Gauche Devlog

< Pipeworks |


Caching formatter procedure

Lisp's format procedure is very un-Schemy. Instead of having a set of composable, orthogonal, do-one-thing-well procedures, format introduces a mini-language that's syntactically and semantically separate from the base language. It is not extendable, loaded with obscure features from the past. Yet it is handy for typical trivial tasks and that's why Gauche (and other Schemes, plus a couple fo SRFIs) offer it. (And to be honest, there's some pleasure to tinker such mini-language implementations.)

Aside from the non-composability, another glaring drawback of format is that it needs to interpret the mini language (format string) at runtime. Most format calls have a literal format string, and it is waste of time to parse it every time format is called. An obvious optimization is to recognize the literal format string and translates the call to format by simpler procedures at compile-time. I believe most CL implemenations do so.

However, Gauche, as well as some other Scheme implementations and SRFI-48, allows the port argument to be omitted. It is convenient, but it indeed makes compile-time transformation difficult. If the first argument of format is a non-literal expression (it is the case if you're passing a port), it is diffuclt for the compiler to recognize if the format string is a constant, even the second argument is a literal string that looks like a format string. If the first expression yields a string at runtime, that is the format string and the literal string is an argument to be shown.

Despite these difficulties, we can still take advantage of literal format string, by caching the format string compilation result at run-time.

It is not exactly the same as memoization. It is difficult to control amount of memoized results, and we only want to cache literal format strings, which needs to be determined at compile time.

So, we implemented a hybrid solution. The compiler macro attached to format checks if possible format string is a literal, and if so, it transforms the call into an internal procedure that takes an extra argument. The extra argument contains the position of the possible literal format string, and a mutable box. The following is the core part of the compile-time transformation:

(define-syntax make-format-transformer
   (^[f r c]
     (match f
       [(_ shared?)
        (quasirename r
            (^[f r c]
              (define (context-literal pos) `(,',shared? ,pos ,(box #f)))
              (match f
                [(_ (? string?) . _)
                 (quasirename r
                   `(format-internal ',(context-literal 0) (list ,@(cdr f))))]
                [(_ _ (? string?) . _)
                 (quasirename r
                   `(format-internal ',(context-literal 1) (list ,@(cdr f))))]
                [(_ _ _ (? string?) . _)
                 (quasirename r
                   `(format-internal ',(context-literal 2) (list ,@(cdr f))))]
                [_ f]))))]))))

(NB: shared? flag is used to share the routine with format and format/ss. We need to check the literal string in first, second and third position, for Gauche's format allows two optional arguments before the format string.)

At run-time, the internal function can see if the literal string is indeed a format string. If so, it computes a formatter procedure based on the format string, and stores it to the mutable box. Subsequent calls will use the computed formatter procedure, skipping parsing and compiling the format string. The caching occurs per-call-site, much like the global variable lookup (we cache the <gloc> object, the result of lookup, in the code vector).

The format-internal procedure checks optional arguments, and calls format-2. Its first argument can be a mutable box introduced by the above macro, if we do know the format string is literal.

(define (format-2 formatter-cache shared? out control fmtstr args)
  (let1 formatter (if formatter-cache
                    (or (unbox formatter-cache)
                        (rlet1 f (formatter-compile fmtstr)
                          (set-box! formatter-cache f)))
                    (formatter-compile fmtstr))
    (case out
       (call-formatter shared? #t formatter (current-output-port) control args)]
      [(#f) (let1 out (open-output-string)
              (call-formatter shared? #f formatter out control args)
              (get-output-string out))]
      [else (call-formatter shared? #t formatter out control args)])))

A micro benchmark shows it's effective. In real code, the effect may not be so prominent, but it does remove worries that you're wasting time for parsing format string.

(define (run p)
  (dotimes [n 1000000]
    (format p "n=~7d 1/n=~8,6f\n" n (/. n))))

(define (main _)
  (time (call-with-output-file "/dev/null" run))

With caching off:

;(time (call-with-output-file "/dev/null" run))
; real  19.796
; user  19.790
; sys    0.000

With caching on:

;(time (call-with-output-file "/dev/null" run))
; real  10.313
; user  10.310
; sys    0.000

Tag: format

Post a comment